Judge permanently dismisses Trump defamation lawsuit against Wall Street Journal

U.S. District Judge Darrin Gayles ruled that the president failed to plausibly allege actual malice over a report on a 2003 Jeffrey Epstein birthday letter.

3 min read
A photo of the Federal Courthouse in Miami, FL, taken by myself on May 13, 2007.
Photo: The original uploader was Miami92 at English Wikipedia.· Public domain· via Wikimedia Commons(opens in a new tab)

Listen

4 min

The rundown

  1. U.S. District Judge Darrin Gayles dismissed President Donald Trump's defamation lawsuit against The Wall Street Journal with prejudice on Saturday, Oct. 31, 2026.
  2. In a 20-page ruling, Gayles found that Trump failed to plausibly allege that the newspaper acted with actual malice when reporting on a 2003 birthday letter to Jeffrey Epstein.
  3. The lawsuit was initially reported as seeking $10 billion in damages, though CBS News reported that Trump sought $20 billion.
  4. A spokesperson for Trump's legal team said the president would continue to pursue the case, and a source familiar with the strategy indicated the ruling would likely be appealed.

U.S. District Judge Darrin Gayles permanently dismissed President Donald Trump's multibillion-dollar defamation lawsuit against The Wall Street Journal on Saturday, Oct. 31, 2026. Gayles dismissed the complaint with prejudice, barring Trump from refiling the case. In a 20-page ruling, the judge found that the president failed to plausibly allege actual malice in the newspaper's reporting on a 2003 birthday letter to the late convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein.

The dispute began on Thursday, July 17, 2025, when The Wall Street Journal published an article describing an album compiled in 2003 by British socialite and Epstein associate Ghislaine Maxwell for Epstein's 50th birthday. According to the report, the album contained a sexually suggestive letter and drawing attributed to Trump and bearing his signature. The House Oversight Committee later obtained a copy of the card provided by Epstein's estate and released it publicly.

Trump filed his defamation lawsuit on Friday, July 18, 2025, naming The Wall Street Journal, News Corp Chairman Emeritus Rupert Murdoch, and associated reporters as defendants in federal court in Miami. The lawsuit was initially reported as seeking $10 billion in damages, though CBS News reported that Trump sought $20 billion. Gayles dismissed the original complaint in April 2026 for failing to establish actual malice, but permitted Trump's attorneys to file an amended version, which they submitted in May 2026.

In his Oct. 31 ruling, Gayles concluded that the amended claims remained vague and conclusory. The judge wrote that Trump's lawsuit attempted to manufacture flaws in the newspaper's reporting. Gayles found that the filing failed to establish that the Journal or its parent company acted with knowledge that the statements were false or with reckless disregard for the truth.

Trump and the White House have denied responsibility for the artwork, note, and signature, asserting that the document is fake. The president's legal team argued that the items were fabricated and that the Journal knowingly published false statements, causing severe financial and reputational harm. A spokesperson for Trump's legal team stated after the dismissal that the president would continue to pursue the case, and a source familiar with the legal strategy said the ruling would likely be appealed.

Attorneys for The Wall Street Journal and parent company Dow Jones argued that the reporting met standard journalistic practices because reporters contacted Trump prior to publication and cited his denials. They also contended that sending a bawdy birthday card is not inherently defamatory and that the complaint failed to demonstrate actual malice.

Under United States defamation law, public figures such as elected officials must prove actual malice to prevail in a lawsuit against a publisher. Actual malice requires showing that a publisher made a false statement with knowledge of its falsity or with reckless disregard for whether it was true or false. Maxwell compiled the birthday album in 2003, five years before Epstein's 2008 conviction in Florida for soliciting a minor.

The dismissal comes amid other legal disputes involving the president and major news organizations, including pending defamation lawsuits against the BBC and The New York Times. In another press dispute, U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly blocked the White House from banning three news outlets on Tuesday, Oct. 14, granting a preliminary injunction that preserved White House hard passes for 78 journalists from CNN, MS NOW, and Politico.

Why it matters

Because Judge Gayles dismissed the amended complaint with prejudice, Trump is barred from refiling the multibillion-dollar defamation suit in district court. The ruling reinforces the high legal threshold public figures face under U.S. defamation law, which requires proving that a publisher acted with knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for the truth.

What's next

A spokesperson for Trump's legal team stated that the president will continue to pursue the case, and a source familiar with the legal strategy indicated that Trump's attorneys plan to appeal the dismissal to a federal appellate court. Trump also continues to litigate separate defamation lawsuits against other news outlets, including the BBC and The New York Times.

Sources · 5 reports

Spotted an error? Write to [email protected]. Tags: Donald Trump, The Wall Street Journal, Defamation, Federal Courts, Jeffrey Epstein.