Judge allows Trump's $10 billion defamation lawsuit against BBC to proceed

U.S. District Judge Jeffrey Kuntz ruled that the president plausibly alleged actual malice over the broadcaster's editing of his Jan. 6 speech.

3 min read
A photo of the Federal Courthouse in Miami, FL, taken by myself on May 13, 2007.
Photo: The original uploader was Miami92 at English Wikipedia.· Public domain· via Wikimedia Commons(opens in a new tab)

Listen

5 min

The rundown

  1. U.S. District Judge Jeffrey Kuntz denied the BBC's motion to dismiss President Donald Trump's $10 billion defamation claim on Tuesday, Nov. 10.
  2. Kuntz ruled that Trump plausibly alleged actual malice based on a documentary clip that spliced together two remarks delivered 55 minutes apart during his Jan. 6, 2021 speech.
  3. The judge dismissed a secondary claim brought under Florida's Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act, finding the documentary was not commercial speech.
  4. The BBC apologized in November 2025 for the edit, acknowledging it gave a mistaken impression, and stated on Tuesday, Nov. 10, that it was surprised by the ruling and would continue to contest the case.

U.S. District Judge Jeffrey Kuntz allowed President Donald Trump's $10 billion defamation lawsuit against the BBC to proceed on Tuesday, Nov. 10. Kuntz, who sits in the Southern District of Florida, denied the British broadcaster's motion to dismiss the primary defamation count, ruling that Trump had plausibly alleged actual malice over the network's editing of his Jan. 6, 2021 speech.

In the same order, Kuntz dismissed a secondary claim Trump brought under Florida's Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act. The judge determined that the documentary at the center of the dispute did not constitute commercial speech.

The lawsuit stems from an episode of the BBC investigative program Panorama titled Trump: A Second Chance, which aired in late October 2024, one week before the U.S. presidential election. The program condensed Trump's 70-minute speech delivered to supporters in Washington on Jan. 6, 2021, prior to the Capitol riot, into a 12-second clip. In doing so, the broadcast spliced together two remarks spoken roughly 55 minutes apart while omitting his call for peace.

In November 2025, the BBC issued a formal apology and BBC Chair Samir Shah sent a letter to the White House regarding the edit. The network acknowledged that the clip gave a mistaken impression that Trump had made a direct call for violent action, though it maintained there was no basis for a defamation lawsuit. Trump filed the $10 billion suit in federal court in Florida in December 2025, alleging defamation and state unfair trade practices violations.

In moving to dismiss the suit, the BBC argued that the editing represented the ordinary condensing of a 70-minute address and did not satisfy legal criteria for defamation, despite regrets over how the segment was compiled. The broadcaster also contended that the program was not broadcast in Florida or the broader United States. Trump and his legal counsel argued that the network intentionally and maliciously doctored the Jan. 6 speech to mislead viewers by omitting calls for peace, causing reputational damage ahead of the 2024 election. Kuntz concluded that the splicing of two remarks delivered 55 minutes apart was sufficient to plausibly allege actual malice.

Trump welcomed the ruling as a victory on social media. The BBC stated that it was surprised by Kuntz's decision to let the defamation count advance, adding that it would continue to contest the case through the legal process.

The decision marks a rare procedural step forward in the president's ongoing legal disputes with news organizations. On Saturday, Oct. 31, U.S. District Judge Darrin Gayles permanently dismissed Trump's defamation lawsuit against The Wall Street Journal, finding in a 20-page ruling that the president failed to plausibly allege actual malice over reporting on a 2003 birthday letter to Jeffrey Epstein. Earlier, on Tuesday, Oct. 14, U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly granted a preliminary injunction that blocked the White House from revoking press passes for 78 journalists from CNN, MS NOW, and Politico.

With the motion to dismiss resolved, the BBC lawsuit continues into the next stages of litigation, where Trump faces an approaching deadline. On Thursday, Oct. 22, a federal magistrate judge ordered Trump to sit for a deposition by Dec. 11 or risk sanctions.

Why it matters

By finding that the splicing of remarks delivered 55 minutes apart plausibly alleges actual malice, the ruling clears a primary legal hurdle for public figures bringing defamation claims in U.S. courts. The decision forces the BBC to continue defending a $10 billion lawsuit in Florida federal court over a documentary that the broadcaster argues was never aired in the United States.

What's next

Trump is under a federal magistrate judge's order to sit for a deposition by Friday, Dec. 11, or risk sanctions. As litigation continues, the BBC must decide whether to seek an interlocutory appeal of Kuntz's denial of the motion to dismiss, while Trump's legal team will ultimately need to substantiate actual malice and prove actual damages from a broadcast not aired in Florida if the case reaches summary judgment or trial.

Sources · 3 reports

Spotted an error? Write to [email protected]. Tags: Donald Trump, BBC, Defamation, Federal Courts, Media.