Federal judge blocks Trump's White House ban on three news outlets
A preliminary injunction preserves press credentials for 78 journalists at CNN, MS NOW, and Politico while their lawsuit proceeds.
Listen
The rundown
- U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly granted a preliminary injunction on Tuesday, Oct. 14, preserving White House hard passes for 78 journalists from CNN, MS NOW, and Politico.
- Kelly found that the administration likely violated the reporters' First and Fifth Amendment rights and produced practically no evidence tying the revocations to national security.
- The ruling maintains access to White House press areas while litigation continues, though it does not mandate access to the Oval Office or Air Force One.
- The Justice Department filed an appeal challenging the preliminary injunction on Wednesday, Oct. 15.
U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly granted a preliminary injunction on Tuesday, Oct. 14, blocking President Donald Trump from barring journalists with CNN, MS NOW, and Politico from White House grounds. Kelly found that the administration likely violated the reporters' First Amendment free speech rights and Fifth Amendment due process protections when it revoked press credentials for 78 journalists across the three news organizations.
The Justice Department filed an appeal challenging the preliminary injunction on Wednesday, Oct. 15. While the litigation proceeds, the injunction preserves the journalists' White House hard passes, which grant physical access to press areas without requiring advance single-day permission.
The dispute began on Friday, Sept. 18, when Trump posted on social media announcing a ban on reporters from CNN, MS NOW, and Politico. The three news organizations filed a joint lawsuit in federal court on Monday, Sept. 21, challenging the credential revocations. On Tuesday, Sept. 22, the White House Press Office sent letters informing the news organizations of the credential revocations and setting a response deadline.
Kelly intervened on Thursday, Sept. 24, issuing a temporary restraining order that restored the journalists' White House press credentials while he considered a longer-term ruling. In his Tuesday decision extending that relief, Kelly rejected the administration's rationale for pulling the passes.
The Trump administration and the Justice Department argued that the president possesses the authority to control credentialing to protect national security and counter falsehoods. Kelly determined that the administration produced practically no evidence connecting the pass revocations to national security concerns when the ban began.
The White House asserted that the excluded news outlets spread falsehoods and maintained that White House access is a privilege rather than a constitutional right. The administration also contended that the press corps has no constitutional right to access the Oval Office. While Kelly ordered the preservation of hard passes for general press areas, his preliminary injunction does not mandate access to the Oval Office or Air Force One.
Lead attorney Theodore Boutrous Jr., representing CNN, MS NOW, and Politico, argued that the ban constituted unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination meant to punish coverage the president disliked. The outlets also contended that the revocations violated Fifth Amendment due process protections by stripping passes without advance notice or an opportunity to respond.
The legal challenge draws on federal circuit precedent in the District of Columbia, which establishes procedural due process protections governing credential revocations. The confrontation is the latest in a series of conflicts between Trump and mainstream news organizations over critical coverage.
Trump has previously restricted access for specific outlets, including the Associated Press.
Why it matters
The injunction prevents the White House from enforcing a credential revocation affecting 78 journalists at three major outlets while the underlying constitutional challenge plays out. While the order secures access to standard White House press areas under First and Fifth Amendment protections, it leaves the administration with discretion over restricted spaces like the Oval Office and Air Force One.
What's next
A federal appeals court will review the Justice Department's Wednesday, Oct. 15 appeal of the preliminary injunction while the broader lawsuit continues in district court. Questions remain regarding whether the administration will attempt to restrict the three outlets from press pools or travel contingents during the litigation.
Sources · 4 reports
Spotted an error? Write to [email protected]. Tags: Donald Trump, White House, First Amendment, Federal Courts, Media.