Federal judge blocks Trump sanctions on two groups aiding the ICC

U.S. District Judge Jesse M. Furman ruled that the February 2025 executive order likely violates the First Amendment rights of two American advocacy organizations.

3 min read
List of the most recent six documents available on Court Listener-RECAP on 2023-04-15 re. w:Hachette v. Internet Archive. The most recent five have already been purchased via RECAP, so anyone can get
Photo: DavidMCEddy· CC BY-SA 4.0· via Wikimedia Commons(opens in a new tab)

Listen

4 min

The rundown

  1. U.S. District Judge Jesse M. Furman issued a preliminary injunction on Tuesday, Oct. 14, barring the Trump administration from enforcing sanctions against Democracy for the Arab World Now and Taxpayer Alliance Against Genocide.
  2. Furman concluded that the administration's February 2025 executive order likely violates the First Amendment as a content-based speech regulation that cannot survive strict scrutiny.
  3. The judge declined to declare the executive order facially unconstitutional and refused to grant a nationwide injunction.
  4. The Trump administration issued the executive order after the International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant.

U.S. District Judge Jesse M. Furman of the Southern District of New York issued a preliminary injunction on Tuesday, Oct. 14, temporarily barring the Trump administration from enforcing sanctions against two American human rights groups assisting the International Criminal Court. The ruling protects Democracy for the Arab World Now and Taxpayer Alliance Against Genocide while their legal challenge proceeds.

In his decision, Furman concluded that the administration's February 2025 executive order authorizing the penalties likely violates the plaintiffs' First Amendment rights. The court found that the measure functions as a content-based regulation of speech that cannot survive strict scrutiny.

At the same time, Furman limited the scope of the relief. He denied the plaintiffs' requests to declare the executive order facially unconstitutional and refused to grant a nationwide injunction that would have barred the administration from enforcing the sanctions against anyone.

Both advocacy organizations had gathered information and evidence for the ICC's inquiry into alleged war crimes in Gaza before challenging the order in federal court. The plaintiffs argued that the sanctions violate First Amendment protections by punishing speech-based advocacy and unlawfully shielding foreign officials from war crimes accountability.

Following the ruling on Tuesday, Oct. 14, Democracy for the Arab World Now, where Omar Shakir serves as executive director, announced that it would immediately resume its advocacy with the International Criminal Court.

The U.S. Department of State declined to discuss the pending litigation directly. However, the department stated that the administration maintains the International Criminal Court poses an intolerable and unacceptable threat to U.S. national sovereignty.

The legal dispute stems from an executive order the Trump administration issued in February 2025. That directive threatened penalties against individuals and entities assisting ICC investigations that Washington deemed a threat to the national security of the United States or its allies.

The administration issued the February 2025 order after the international tribunal issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant over alleged war crimes in Gaza. On Friday, Oct. 9, days before Furman's ruling, the Trump administration also imposed direct financial sanctions on the International Criminal Court.

The injunction is the latest federal court action addressing First Amendment challenges to the administration, following a separate ruling in which a Federal judge blocks Trump's White House ban on three news outlets.

Why it matters

The preliminary injunction allows Democracy for the Arab World Now and Taxpayer Alliance Against Genocide to resume their work with the International Criminal Court without immediate threat of U.S. penalties. Because Judge Furman declined to issue a nationwide injunction or strike down the February 2025 executive order on its face, the sanctions regime remains in effect for other individuals and entities not party to the lawsuit.

What's next

Democracy for the Arab World Now plans to immediately resume its advocacy with the tribunal. Meanwhile, the administration must decide whether to appeal the preliminary injunction to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, and other groups or individuals assisting the ICC could file similar lawsuits seeking protection.

Sources · 3 reports

Spotted an error? Write to [email protected]. Tags: International Criminal Court, First Amendment, Sanctions, Trump administration, Federal courts.