Trump defends Hegseth while noting easier path to replace him before January

The president is consulting advisers on the defense secretary's future as administration officials blame the Iran war for Republican midterm defeats.

3 min read
Москва - Дом Правительства РФ на закате.
Photo: Юрий Д.К.· CC BY 4.0· via Wikimedia Commons(opens in a new tab)

Listen

4 min

The rundown

  1. President Donald Trump told ABC News on Thursday, Nov. 5, that he intends to retain Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, but noted confirming a successor would be easier before Democrats take control of Congress.
  2. Trump has privately consulted advisers on whether Hegseth should remain at the Pentagon following Republican losses in the Tuesday, Nov. 3 midterm elections, according to reports.
  3. Internal administration critics blame Hegseth for encouraging Trump to enter the eight-month war with Iran, which Vice President JD Vance and others cited as a driver of the midterm defeats.
  4. Advisers have floated Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis as a possible replacement during the lame-duck Senate session, while Trump suggested Hegseth for an open Tennessee Senate seat.

President Donald Trump told ABC News on Thursday, Nov. 5, that he intends to keep Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth in his post. In the same interview, Trump acknowledged that confirming a replacement would be simpler during the current Republican-controlled lame-duck session before Democrats take control of Congress in January.

Behind the scenes, Hegseth's standing at the Pentagon faces scrutiny following Republican losses in the Tuesday, Nov. 3 midterm elections. Reports emerged on Wednesday, Nov. 4, that Trump has privately consulted advisers on whether Hegseth should remain in the cabinet.

Even as those discussions took place, Trump told reporters on Wednesday, Nov. 4, that Hegseth was doing a very good job. Trump also suggested that the defense secretary would be popular if appointed to fill the U.S. Senate seat being vacated by Tennessee Sen. Marsha Blackburn, the state's governor-elect.

If Trump chooses to replace Hegseth before the current congressional session ends, advisers have floated Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis as a possible nominee, according to reports. Hegseth remained publicly defiant on Thursday, Nov. 5, as internal scrutiny and Democratic oversight threats grew.

The friction inside the administration stems from fallout over the eight-month conflict with Iran. As covered in our rundown on how Vance blames Iran war for Republican midterm losses as Trump defends strikes, Vice President JD Vance and other administration figures attributed the party's electoral defeat to public backlash over the military campaign.

Internal administration critics specifically fault Hegseth for encouraging Trump to enter the war with Iran, arguing that the conflict contributed to the midterm losses, according to reports. White House spokeswoman Anna Kelly pushed back against the criticism, saying Trump maintains full confidence in Hegseth and commends his leadership on military operations and Pentagon reforms.

The debate over Pentagon leadership comes at a delicate moment in the conflict, days after Qatar advances U.S.-Iran deal to reopen Strait of Hormuz as Trump threatens new strikes. While Secretary of State Marco Rubio said on Saturday, Oct. 31, that Trump prefers a diplomatic solution, the president noted the U.S. military could strike remaining Iranian targets within 10 minutes.

Democrats won majorities in both the House and the Senate on Tuesday, Nov. 3, securing at least 54 Senate seats and passing the 218-seat threshold in the House. Before winning those majorities, congressional Democrats had already initiated efforts to impeach Hegseth.

The transition to Democratic control in January will complicate Trump's ability to confirm cabinet nominees in the Senate. Ahead of the vote, Trump says he will become 'Mr. Veto' if Democrats win Congress, and the White House has prepared strategies to govern through executive actions while bracing for Democratic investigations into defense contracts and administration records.

Why it matters

The transition to a Democratic-controlled Senate in January gives Trump a narrow window during the lame-duck session to confirm a new defense secretary with a Republican majority. Leaving Hegseth in place exposes the administration to potential Democratic impeachment proceedings and oversight investigations as the eight-month war with Iran continues.

What's next

Trump must decide before the new Congress convenes in January whether to nominate a successor such as DeSantis while Republicans still hold the Senate. Meanwhile, incoming Democratic majorities will decide whether to advance their impeachment efforts against Hegseth when they assume power, and Tennessee will move to fill Blackburn's Senate seat.

Sources · 3 reports

Spotted an error? Write to [email protected]. Tags: Donald Trump, Pete Hegseth, Department of Defense, Iran war, Midterm elections, Ron DeSantis.