Supreme Court leaves block on Trump policy restricting transgender prison care
The unsigned order requires the Federal Bureau of Prisons to continue providing hormone therapy and social accommodations while litigation proceeds.
Listen
The rundown
- The Supreme Court on Wednesday, Oct. 21, denied a Trump administration emergency request to enforce restrictions on gender-affirming care for federal inmates.
- Associate Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito publicly noted they would have granted the stay.
- The blocked February 2025 policy prohibited transition surgeries, hormone therapy, and social accommodations while maintaining psychiatric care.
- Lower courts blocked the policy after finding the government failed to consider prior operational experience or provide evidence that past treatments compromised safety.
The Supreme Court on Wednesday, Oct. 21, rejected an emergency application from the Trump administration, leaving in place a lower court injunction that requires the Federal Bureau of Prisons to continue providing gender-affirming care and social accommodations to transgender inmates.
The court's unsigned order keeps the restrictions blocked while legal challenges proceed. Associate Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito publicly noted that they would have granted the administration's request for a stay, though they did not issue a written opinion.
The dispute began in January 2025, when President Donald Trump signed an executive order directing federal agencies to recognize only male and female sexes and restricting federal funds from supporting gender-transition procedures. In February 2025, the Federal Bureau of Prisons issued a policy prohibiting gender-transition surgeries, phasing out hormone therapies, and halting social accommodations such as wigs, binders, and makeup for inmates diagnosed with gender dysphoria, while continuing psychiatric care.
Incarcerated plaintiffs subsequently challenged the restrictions in a class-action lawsuit. According to the lawsuit, the class represents approximately 1,000 federal inmates diagnosed with gender dysphoria, including an estimated 800 individuals receiving hormone therapy.
In June 2026, U.S. District Judge Royce Lamberth issued a preliminary injunction barring the Bureau of Prisons from enforcing the policy. Lamberth found that the government provided no evidence from its medical personnel indicating that previous treatments were ineffective or compromised safety.
A divided panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit declined to lift the injunction in a 2-1 decision in September 2026. The appellate panel concluded that the agency failed to adequately consider its prior operational experience before altering the rules, prompting the Justice Department to file the emergency stay request with the Supreme Court.
In court filings, the Justice Department argued that providing gender-affirming care undermines institutional security, invites inmate resentment, and creates safety risks for recipients. The administration maintained that the revised policy is necessary to avoid inmate friction and adhere to the president's executive order. Following the Supreme Court's order on Wednesday, Oct. 21, the White House stated that it would continue trying to protect Americans from these medical practices.
Lawyers for the incarcerated plaintiffs and the American Civil Liberties Union argued that denying medically necessary gender-affirming care causes severe psychological and physical harm, violating the Eighth Amendment's protection against cruel and unusual punishment. According to the ACLU, the Federal Bureau of Prisons has provided hormone treatments to inmates diagnosed with gender dysphoria since 1992.
Although the Supreme Court's 6-3 conservative majority has previously upheld restrictions on transgender athletes in public school sports and state bans on youth gender-affirming care, lower court injunctions have stalled several executive branch policy changes across multiple federal agencies. In recent rulings, a Federal judge blocks Trump's White House ban on three news outlets and another Federal judge blocks Trump sanctions on two groups aiding the ICC, keeping both administration directives on hold during litigation.
The denial of the emergency stay also comes during an active week for the justices, who announced on Monday, Oct. 19, that the Supreme Court to hear challenge to Maryland middle school magnet admissions.
Why it matters
The order ensures that approximately 1,000 federal inmates diagnosed with gender dysphoria, including an estimated 800 receiving hormone therapy, according to the class-action lawsuit, will retain access to medical treatments and social accommodations while the legal challenge continues.
What's next
The lawsuit, Kingdom v. Trump, will return to the lower federal courts to proceed on the merits of the plaintiffs' Eighth Amendment challenge. The Supreme Court also has other pending transgender-rights cases on its docket, including disputes over high school sports and state parental consent laws.
Sources · 8 reports
Spotted an error? Write to [email protected]. Tags: Supreme Court, Federal Bureau of Prisons, Donald Trump, Justice Department, ACLU.