Supreme Court allows New Hampshire to ban student IDs at polling places
The unsigned order reinstates a state directive barring voters from using student identification for any purpose in the November midterms.
Listen
The rundown
- The U.S. Supreme Court granted an emergency request on Thursday, Oct. 22, reinstating New Hampshire's ban on student IDs at polling places for the Tuesday, Nov. 3, midterm elections.
- The unsigned order vacated an injunction from U.S. District Judge Joseph Laplante, who found Secretary of State David Scanlan exceeded state law by barring student IDs as secondary proof of identity.
- The court's majority cited the principle that lower federal courts should not alter election rules shortly before voting begins.
- Associate Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented, writing that the lower court acted properly to ensure voters have accurate information about state requirements.
The U.S. Supreme Court granted an emergency request from New Hampshire officials and the Republican National Committee on Thursday, Oct. 22, reinstating a directive that prohibits voters from using student identification for any purpose at polling places in the Tuesday, Nov. 3, midterm elections.
In an unsigned order, the court vacated a lower court injunction that had blocked the policy. The justices stated that lower federal courts should not alter voting rules in the weeks immediately preceding an election.
The dispute began in April 2026, when New Hampshire lawmakers amended election statutes to remove student IDs from the list of accepted primary photo identification at voting precincts. Under state law, voters who lack primary photo identification can still present alternative proof to establish their identity under a general verification standard.
Following the April legislation, New Hampshire Secretary of State David Scanlan issued administrative guidance to poll workers. Scanlan's directive prohibited student IDs from being considered for any purpose, barring them even as backup evidence under the state's secondary verification rule.
The Coalition for Open Democracy, a nonprofit voting rights advocacy organization, challenged Scanlan's policy in federal court. On Friday, Oct. 2, U.S. District Judge Joseph Laplante blocked the guidance, finding that state officials exceeded the statutory ban by prohibiting student IDs as secondary proof of identity.
After the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals declined to pause Laplante's order, New Hampshire officials and the Republican National Committee asked the Supreme Court to intervene. They argued that lower courts should not change election administration rules shortly before voting begins without compelling justification.
Associate Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented from the Thursday, Oct. 22, order. Jackson argued that the district court's decision should not be disturbed because it was justified to ensure voters receive accurate information about state voting requirements.
In its legal challenge, the Coalition for Open Democracy argued that barring student IDs places an unconstitutional burden on voting access and improperly targets younger citizens.
The order arrives less than two weeks before the Tuesday, Nov. 3, general election, where New Hampshire voters will decide a U.S. Senate race between former U.S. Sen. John E. Sununu, the Republican candidate, and U.S. Rep. Chris Pappas, the Democratic nominee.
The decision follows other pre-election disputes over voting rules across the country, including in California, where the Justice Department threatens California with lawsuit over voter rolls over the handling of mail-in ballots. It also comes two days after a separate public discussion of the judiciary's role in elections, in which Justice Kagan warns Supreme Court rulings fuel polarization and hurt democracy, citing past decisions on voting rights and redistricting.
Why it matters
The ruling immediately changes identification rules at New Hampshire polling stations for the Tuesday, Nov. 3, midterm elections, prohibiting poll workers from accepting student IDs even as secondary proof of identity during the U.S. Senate race between Republican John E. Sununu and Democrat Chris Pappas.
What's next
New Hampshire will enforce the complete ban on student IDs at polling places during the midterm election on Tuesday, Nov. 3, while federal courts may hold a full trial on the merits of the state law and administrative guidance after the election.
Sources · 3 reports
Spotted an error? Write to [email protected]. Tags: Supreme Court, New Hampshire, Voting rights, 2026 midterms, Ketanji Brown Jackson.