Justice Kagan warns Supreme Court rulings fuel polarization and hurt democracy

Speaking at Catholic University ahead of the midterms, Kagan criticized the conservative majority on voting rights, gerrymandering, and campaign finance.

3 min read
The interior of Court 1, the largest of the three courtrooms of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom in Middlesex Guildhall, London, England.
Photo: Diliff· CC BY-SA 3.0· via Wikimedia Commons(opens in a new tab)

Listen

4 min

The rundown

  1. Associate Justice Elena Kagan stated on Tuesday, Oct. 20, that Supreme Court rulings on voting rights, partisan gerrymandering, and campaign finance have deepened polarization and damaged democratic processes.
  2. Kagan argued that the court's 2019 decision barring federal courts from policing partisan gerrymandering triggered an aggressive push by both parties to create safe districts.
  3. Following redistricting in Texas encouraged by President Donald Trump, several states, including California, redrew congressional maps ahead of the Nov. 3 midterms.
  4. Kagan also questioned a 2026 decision expanding presidential authority over independent federal agencies, while rejecting characterizations that the conservative majority simply rubber-stamps Trump.

Associate Justice Elena Kagan stated on Tuesday, Oct. 20, that rulings by the Supreme Court's conservative majority have deepened national polarization and damaged democratic functioning. Speaking two weeks before the Tuesday, Nov. 3 midterm elections, Kagan said decisions weakening voting protections, permitting unchecked campaign spending, and declining to curb partisan gerrymandering have distorted representation.

Kagan delivered her remarks at the Catholic University of America's Columbus School of Law. Her critique of the 6-3 conservative majority addressed both election law and the constitutional separation of powers.

A central focus of Kagan's remarks was the Supreme Court's 2019 ruling on partisan gerrymandering. In that decision, the conservative majority held that federal courts lack constitutional authority to restrict partisan gerrymandering, leaving redistricting disputes to state courts and legislatures.

Kagan criticized the 2019 ruling, arguing it prompted a competitive effort by both political parties to draw uncompetitive districts. Following redistricting moves initiated in Texas at the urging of President Donald Trump, several states, including California, redrew congressional maps ahead of the Nov. 3 midterms.

Kagan contended that gerrymandered districts push politicians toward ideological extremes because nominees must focus primarily on primary elections. Those redrawn House districts will be contested alongside key legislative races, where nine competitive Senate races will decide control of the chamber in November, with Republicans defending a 53-47 majority.

Beyond redistricting, Kagan pointed to decisions narrowing provisions of the Voting Rights Act of 1965 and striking down statutory limits on political spending. In June 2026, the Supreme Court struck down campaign finance restrictions in its latest campaign funding ruling, with the conservative majority invalidating those limits on First Amendment grounds.

Kagan also criticized a ruling from earlier in 2026 that granted the president expanded control over independent federal agencies created by Congress. In that decision, the conservative majority invalidated statutory agency restrictions on constitutional grounds.

At the same time, Kagan rejected arguments that the Supreme Court's 6-3 conservative majority acts merely as a rubber stamp for Trump. To support that point, she cited rulings by the court that rejected Trump's sweeping tariffs.

Presidential authority and trade policy remain central issues ahead of the November elections. In Congress, House Democrats plan a 100-days agenda targeting Trump's executive actions and costs, including votes within the first 100 hours on measures undoing Trump's tariffs if Democrats win the majority. Meanwhile, in a Fox News poll where Trump's approval fell to 36 percent on Wednesday, Oct. 14, voters favored Democratic candidates over Republicans on the generic congressional ballot by 54 percent to 45 percent.

Why it matters

Kagan's remarks offer a direct public critique by a sitting justice of how the 6-3 conservative majority's rulings on voting rights, campaign finance, and partisan gerrymandering shape American elections. Her warning comes immediately before the Nov. 3 midterms, which will be contested under congressional maps newly redrawn in several states, including Texas and California.

What's next

Voters will cast ballots in the midterm elections on Tuesday, Nov. 3, testing how recent redistricting changes affect the balance of power in Congress. Meanwhile, the Supreme Court continues its current term, leaving open whether the justices will take up additional challenges to state-level congressional maps or federal agency structures.

Sources · 4 reports

Spotted an error? Write to [email protected]. Tags: Supreme Court, Elena Kagan, Redistricting, Voting Rights, Campaign Finance, Donald Trump.