Justice Department asks Supreme Court to allow Big Bend border wall construction
Solicitor General D. John Sauer petitioned the justices to lift a district court injunction that halted more than 300 miles of barriers and roads in West Texas.
Listen
The rundown
- The Justice Department filed an emergency application with the Supreme Court on Wednesday, Oct. 21, to lift an injunction blocking border wall construction in West Texas.
- U.S. District Judge Kathleen Cardone halted the work earlier in October, ruling that Homeland Security officials exceeded statutory authority in waiving environmental laws.
- The federal government cited more than 89,000 apprehensions between 2021 and 2025 to classify the Big Bend Sector as an area of high illegal entry.
- Plaintiffs argue the sector accounts for just 0.3% to 2.2% of southern border apprehensions and say the construction will irrevocably damage parklands and cultural sites.
The Justice Department asked the Supreme Court on Wednesday, Oct. 21, to lift a lower-court injunction and allow border wall and infrastructure construction to resume across the Big Bend Sector of West Texas. U.S. Solicitor General D. John Sauer filed the emergency application after a federal district judge halted the Trump administration's plans to build more than 300 miles of barriers and roads in the region.
The legal dispute began after the Department of Homeland Security announced the Big Bend construction projects in February 2026, invoking federal statutory authority to waive environmental and administrative reviews. In April 2026, a coalition including an environmental nonprofit, a riverboat guide, and a religious group sued to challenge the waivers and the planned construction. Contractors began building a 47-mile section of border barrier in September 2026.
Earlier in October, U.S. District Judge Kathleen Cardone of the Western District of Texas granted a preliminary injunction halting the construction work. Cardone concluded that Homeland Security officials—under former Secretary Kristi Noem and current Secretary Markwayne Mullin—exceeded their statutory authority by waiving standard environmental and preservation laws. After Cardone declined to pause her order, Sauer appealed directly to the Supreme Court's emergency docket.
The filing comes during an active week at the high court, where the justices announced on Monday, Oct. 19, that the Supreme Court to hear challenge to Maryland middle school magnet admissions. Meanwhile, the Trump administration has faced separate legal setbacks in federal district court, where on Tuesday, Oct. 14, a Federal judge blocks Trump sanctions on two groups aiding the ICC after concluding the administration's executive order likely violates the First Amendment.
In the Supreme Court filing, Sauer argued that the district court injunction lacks merit, disrupts federal border security operations, and hinders efforts to stop drug smuggling and unauthorized crossings. A 1996 federal immigration statute allows the Secretary of Homeland Security to waive laws to expedite physical barriers in areas of high illegal entry. To support that designation, the government cited more than 89,000 apprehensions in the Big Bend Sector between 2021 and 2025.
The plaintiffs, including the Center for Biological Diversity, represented by senior attorney Zeynep Graves, dispute that classification. They argued in court filings that the Big Bend Sector ranks last in total southern border apprehensions, accounting for 0.3% to 2.2% of border-wide apprehensions despite covering a quarter of the southern boundary. The challengers maintain that only Congress holds constitutional authority to authorize comprehensive wall construction and argue the projects will irrevocably damage wilderness and cultural resources.
The Big Bend Sector spans more than 500 miles of the U.S.-Mexico border across 77 Texas counties, encompassing rugged public lands including Big Bend National Park and Big Bend Ranch State Park. The administration awarded five construction contracts in the area before the litigation stopped work. Before the injunction, U.S. Customs and Border Protection, led by Commissioner Rodney Scott, had paused construction inside Big Bend National Park through late September following local and bipartisan opposition.
Why it matters
The dispute tests the scope of a 1996 federal statute that lets the Secretary of Homeland Security waive environmental and preservation laws in areas of high illegal entry. The outcome will determine whether federal contractors can proceed with more than 300 miles of planned border barriers and roads across 77 Texas counties, including public parklands.
What's next
The Supreme Court will decide whether to grant an emergency stay lifting Judge Cardone's injunction or refer the underlying statutory waiver dispute for expedited briefing and oral argument. If the justices lift the block, questions remain over what specific infrastructure federal contractors will build inside Big Bend National Park.
Sources · 3 reports
Spotted an error? Write to [email protected]. Tags: Supreme Court, Department of Justice, Department of Homeland Security, Border Wall, Texas.