Todd Blanche declines to rule out Justice Department action on election certification

The attorney general said the department does not intend to improperly interfere in state processes, while Senate Democrats said they are prepared to contest any federal challenges.

3 min read
WASHINGTON (October 3, 2023) Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas speaks during a press conference at the Department of Justice on detailed efforts by US Customs and Border Protection and Ho
Photo: DHSgov· Public domain· via Wikimedia Commons(opens in a new tab)

Listen

4 min

The rundown

  1. Attorney General Todd Blanche declined on Thursday, Oct. 22, to rule out Justice Department intervention in state election certification under hypothetical extreme circumstances.
  2. Blanche stated that the department does not intend to improperly interfere with state certification and is focused on verifying voter eligibility.
  3. The U.S. Constitution and federal law assign election administration and certification to state and local officials, with no federal statute authorizing the Justice Department to delay certification.
  4. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer said Democrats have prepared for months to challenge any federal interference legally and politically.
  5. A federal judge temporarily restricted certain Justice Department election operations across nine states, while the department separately sued California over mail-in ballots.

Attorney General Todd Blanche declined to rule out the possibility that the Justice Department could intervene in state election certification during the midterm elections. Speaking to reporters in Norfolk, Virginia, on Thursday, Oct. 22, Blanche said he could not dismiss federal action under hypothetical extreme scenarios regarding state certification.

Blanche maintained that the Justice Department does not intend to improperly interfere with state election certification processes. He added that the department does not plan to disrupt certification, saying its focus is ensuring that only eligible citizens vote.

Blanche did not specify what legal mechanism the department might cite if it sought to intervene in state certification. Under the U.S. Constitution and federal law, election administration and certification authority belong to state and local officials rather than the federal government. Federal law restricts the Justice Department's election role to enforcing civil rights protections and prosecuting specific statutory election crimes, with no statutes authorizing the department to challenge ballots directly or delay certification.

Democratic leaders criticized Blanche's remarks on Thursday, Oct. 22. In a post on X, U.S. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer of New York contended that the comments reflect an effort by President Donald Trump's administration to challenge legitimate election results. Schumer said Senate Democrats have prepared for months to counter potential administration challenges legally and politically.

Blanche's comments follow escalating legal disputes over federal involvement in state election administration ahead of the Tuesday, Nov. 3 midterms. In a separate court action, a federal judge temporarily restricted certain Justice Department election-related field operations and interviews across nine states through Election Day. The judge stayed the ruling until Friday evening to allow the administration time to appeal.

The department has also sued California election officials to block the counting of mail-in ballots from thousands of individuals flagged by federal authorities as suspected noncitizens until their eligibility is confirmed. According to the California secretary of state's office, the federal government gave state officials 48 hours to review approximately 20,000 names. Studies and historical election records show that voting by noncitizens in federal elections is exceedingly rare.

The lawsuit followed an earlier dispute in which the Justice Department threatens California with lawsuit over voter rolls if state officials did not vet the federal list of suspected noncitizens and segregate their mail-in ballots. State officials rejected that earlier demand, arguing that the federal government lacks authority over state voter rolls and that federal law bars systemic roll removals within 90 days of an election.

Why it matters

The U.S. Constitution and federal law assign election administration and certification authority to state and local officials. Because no federal statutes authorize the Justice Department to challenge ballots directly or delay state certification, any federal attempt to intervene in midterm results would test constitutional and statutory limits on executive authority.

What's next

A federal judge's temporary restriction on Justice Department election-related field operations and interviews across nine states remains stayed until Friday evening to allow the administration to appeal. Federal litigation over California's handling of mail-in ballots also remains pending ahead of the Tuesday, Nov. 3 midterms.

Sources · 3 reports

Spotted an error? Write to [email protected]. Tags: Todd Blanche, Department of Justice, Chuck Schumer, Midterm elections, California.