Alaska governor orders probe into Peltola campaign over second Dan Sullivan on ballot
State and federal officials are investigating reports that Democratic operatives recruited a retired schoolteacher with the same name as incumbent Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan.
Listen
The rundown
- Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy ordered the Department of Public Safety on Wednesday, Oct. 28, to investigate whether Democratic Senate nominee Mary Peltola's campaign broke state laws.
- The inquiry follows a New York Times report that Peltola campaign staff and Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee aides recruited Dan J. Sullivan to draw votes from Sen. Dan S. Sullivan.
- On Thursday, Oct. 29, the U.S. Department of Justice issued dozens of subpoenas and House Oversight Committee Chair James Comer launched an inquiry into the recruitment effort.
- Peltola, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, and Dan J. Sullivan denied coordination or any intention to mislead voters.
- Legal and election experts said recruiting candidates to enter a race is generally legal unless it involves bribery, coercion, or perjury.
Republican Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy directed the state Department of Public Safety on Wednesday, Oct. 28, to investigate whether Democratic U.S. Senate nominee Mary Peltola's campaign broke state criminal or civil laws. The order followed an investigation published the same day by The New York Times reporting that Peltola's campaign staff and aides with the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee coordinated to recruit a spoiler candidate named Dan J. Sullivan to draw votes from incumbent Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan. By Thursday, Oct. 29, the report had also prompted a congressional inquiry and dozens of federal subpoenas.
On Thursday, Oct. 29, the U.S. Department of Justice issued at least three dozen subpoenas and document preservation requests to Peltola's campaign and to Dan J. Sullivan, according to reporting on the investigation. Republican U.S. Rep. James Comer, chair of the House Oversight Committee, also opened an inquiry on Thursday, Oct. 29, requesting transcribed interviews with former Peltola campaign manager Elisa Rios and Democratic political operative Jerid Kurtz. Peltola dismissed Rios in August 2026, the same month state and federal grand jury subpoenas were initially issued regarding the second Sullivan's campaign.
Peltola and the DSCC publicly denied having any role in Dan J. Sullivan's candidacy. On Thursday, Oct. 29, Peltola stated that she knew nothing about his campaign and had no interest in tricking voters. According to news reports, Rios initially told reporters that Peltola knew about the operation, though Rios subsequently retracted her statements. Dan J. Sullivan, a retired schoolteacher with no prior political experience, stated that he entered the race independently without coordination and with no intention of tricking voters.
Republican officials and the Trump administration contend that intentionally recruiting a same-name candidate to confuse voters undermines electoral integrity. President Donald Trump asserted that the recruitment effort amounted to criminal voter fraud and urged that Peltola be barred from the ballot and prosecuted. During the week of Oct. 19, the Department of Justice filed a federal lawsuit seeking to delay or block election certification if the incumbent senator loses, citing potential voter confusion.
Legal and election experts stated that recruiting candidates to enter a race is generally legal provided no bribes, coercion, or perjury are involved. Dan J. Sullivan filed to run as an independent conservative candidate in May 2026. In June 2026, the Alaska Supreme Court rejected Republican legal challenges and confirmed his right to appear on the four-candidate general election ballot.
The controversy unfolds days before the Tuesday, Nov. 3 midterm elections. Alaska uses a top-four primary and a ranked-choice general election system in which voters rank candidates in order of preference. The contest between Dan S. Sullivan and Peltola is one of nine competitive Senate races that will decide control of the chamber in November, where Republicans are defending a 53-47 majority. The state has drawn national focus, including during October when Trump shifted his midterm travel to conservative states such as Alaska to boost base turnout.
Why it matters
The Alaska contest is one of six toss-up races that will determine whether Republicans maintain their 53-47 Senate majority in the Tuesday, Nov. 3 election. Because Alaska uses ranked-choice voting and features two candidates named Dan Sullivan on a four-person ballot, voter confusion or litigation delaying certification could directly affect control of the chamber.
What's next
Voters cast ballots on Tuesday, Nov. 3. Meanwhile, the Alaska Department of Public Safety will review whether state statutes were violated, the House Oversight Committee will pursue interviews with Rios and Kurtz, and a federal court must rule on the Justice Department's lawsuit seeking to block certification if Sen. Dan S. Sullivan loses.
Sources · 7 reports
Spotted an error? Write to [email protected]. Tags: Alaska, Mary Peltola, Dan Sullivan, Mike Dunleavy, 2026 midterms, Department of Justice.