Prediction markets anticipate Democratic midterm sweep after $21 billion October

Kalshi and Polymarket odds aligned with most Democratic victories on Tuesday, Nov. 3, despite an upset in South Carolina and misses earlier in 2026.

2 min read
The Polymarket is NYCs first free grocery store, which was only a pop-up for about 5 days. I did not go inside the store though
Photo: TriStateGuy· CC BY-SA 4.0· via Wikimedia Commons(opens in a new tab)

Listen

4 min

The rundown

  1. Online prediction markets Kalshi and Polymarket accurately signaled most Democratic victories in the hours before polls closed on Tuesday, Nov. 3.
  2. Combined monthly trading volume across the two platforms reached a record $21 billion in October 2026, up from $4 million in October 2022.
  3. A Democratic candidate named Andrews won in South Carolina, defying platform odds.
  4. The Associated Press, CNN, The Wall Street Journal, and CNBC entered agreements to integrate live prediction market odds into their election coverage.

Online prediction markets including Kalshi and Polymarket accurately signaled broad Democratic victories in the hours before polls closed on Tuesday, Nov. 3. Election outcomes confirmed on Wednesday, Nov. 4, matched the platforms' projections of dominant Democratic gains across the country. The forecasts reinforced the expanding footprint of event contract platforms in American political forecasting.

The midterm calls capped a period of rapid financial growth for the sector. Combined monthly trading volume on Polymarket, led by founder and Chief Executive Shayne Coplan, and rival platform Kalshi reached a record $21 billion in October 2026. Ahead of the 2022 midterm elections, combined October trading volume on the two platforms totaled just over $4 million.

Prediction platforms allow users to buy and sell binary event contracts that update dynamically as probability estimates. Not every contest followed the market consensus on Tuesday, Nov. 3. In South Carolina, a Democratic candidate named Andrews won in defiance of prediction market odds.

The largely accurate midterm performance followed several high-profile forecasting misses earlier in 2026. On Sunday, Oct. 25, Polymarket odds favored Brazilian presidential candidate Flávio Bolsonaro at roughly 80 percent on election day, before incumbent President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva won the runoff. Both Polymarket and Kalshi also diverged from actual election results in Serbia's snap parliamentary election and in U.S. primaries in Wisconsin, Los Angeles, and Illinois.

Those discrepancies have fueled an ongoing debate over the reliability of financial markets as political barometers. Prediction market operators and proponents argue that market prices aggregate the collective judgment and financial commitment of independent traders, producing faster and more accurate forecasts than traditional opinion polling. Skeptics and market analysts counter that platform odds measure win probability rather than vote margins, which can exaggerate minor leads and leave markets vulnerable to high-profile forecasting errors and potential distortion.

Once operating on the fringes of finance, prediction platforms expanded rapidly under regulatory shifts overseen by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. Under Chair Mike Selig, the commission has stated that event contracts can sometimes forecast outcomes better than polling. Platform prominence grew after markets anticipated Donald Trump's 2024 presidential victory while traditional polls showed a tie.

During the 2026 cycle, mainstream media outlets integrated the platforms directly into their election coverage. The Associated Press, CNN, The Wall Street Journal, and CNBC entered agreements to feature live prediction market odds as Americans voted in the midterm elections.

Why it matters

With monthly trading volume surging from $4 million in October 2022 to $21 billion in October 2026 and media partnerships with the Associated Press, CNN, The Wall Street Journal, and CNBC, prediction markets have moved from the financial fringes into mainstream election coverage.

What's next

Analysts and regulators face open questions over whether federal authorities will adjust oversight of political event contracts following the record $21 billion October trading volume, as well as how closely state and congressional race probabilities tracked final vote margins and which specific projections beyond South Carolina defied platform favorites.

Sources · 3 reports

Spotted an error? Write to [email protected]. Tags: Prediction markets, Polymarket, Kalshi, 2026 midterms, Commodity Futures Trading Commission.