Brazilian court orders Meta to ensure equal algorithm reach in runoff

A justice on Brazil's top electoral court ordered Meta to apply uniform platform and AI rules to Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva and Flávio Bolsonaro or face daily fines.

3 min read
Logo of the Superior Electoral Court/Tribunal (Brazil)
Photo: Tribunal Superior Eleitoral· Public domain· via Wikimedia Commons(opens in a new tab)

Listen

5 min

The rundown

  1. Justice Marco Aurélio Bellizze ordered Meta on Thursday, Oct. 15, to guarantee equal algorithmic treatment for presidential candidates Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva and Flávio Bolsonaro ahead of the Sunday, Oct. 25 runoff.
  2. The ruling prohibits uneven restrictions on distribution or search results across Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp, subject to daily fines of 500,000 reais ($98,000).
  3. Lula's campaign alleged that Meta suppressed his organic reach while boosting Bolsonaro and that WhatsApp's Meta AI refused to generate images for Lula.
  4. Meta denied political bias, stating on Sunday, Oct. 11, that it adheres to Brazilian electoral law and attributing platform disruptions to international technical glitches.

A justice on Brazil's Superior Electoral Court ordered Meta on Thursday, Oct. 15, to ensure equal platform treatment for President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva and conservative challenger Senator Flávio Bolsonaro ahead of the Sunday, Oct. 25 presidential runoff. Justice Marco Aurélio Bellizze issued an injunction requiring the technology company to eliminate algorithmic restrictions on Lula's campaign and apply uniform rules across its artificial intelligence tools.

Under the ruling, Meta is prohibited from curbing political distribution or search results in an imbalanced manner across Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp. The court set a daily fine of 500,000 reais ($98,000) if the company fails to comply with the mandate.

The decision follows a formal complaint filed by Lula's campaign after the incumbent president publicly challenged Meta's platform reach on Wednesday, Oct. 14. Represented by campaign lawyers Gean Ferreira and Evelyn Santos, Lula's legal filing alleged that Meta subjected his posts to unjustified reductions in reach while artificially inflating visibility for accounts aligned with Bolsonaro, the son of former President Jair Bolsonaro.

The complaint also targeted the company's generative artificial intelligence features, which have drawn broader scrutiny globally as eight states sue OpenAI over safety disclosures as FTC probes AI risks. According to Lula's campaign, WhatsApp's Meta AI tool refused to generate campaign images for Lula while permitting the creation of pro-Bolsonaro content. Bellizze's order specifically mandates that Meta apply identical criteria to both presidential campaigns within its Meta AI tools.

Meta has rejected the allegations of political interference. In a statement to the electoral court on Sunday, Oct. 11, following initial complaints from Lula voters, the company maintained that it fully complies with Brazilian election regulations and provides equal access to candidates. Meta attributed the platform disruptions reported by users to broader technical glitches affecting multiple countries rather than algorithmic bias.

The legal dispute comes during a tightly contested campaign before the Sunday, Oct. 25 vote. In the first round of the presidential election on Sunday, Oct. 4, Bolsonaro secured 47% of the vote compared to 45% for Lula, sending the race to a runoff.

Both candidates have sought to consolidate voter support in the final days of the race, including through major legislative measures as Brazil's Senate approves five-day workweek ahead of presidential runoff on Thursday, Oct. 15, after Bolsonaro reversed his opposition to the labor reform on Tuesday, Oct. 13. Brazilian electoral authorities enforce strict regulations governing campaign fairness, advertising, and public distribution across digital platforms during national elections.

Why it matters

The injunction establishes a direct judicial mandate over how social media algorithms and generative AI tools operate during the final days of a close national election. With Bolsonaro leading Lula 47% to 45% after the first round, any shifts in digital visibility across Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp could influence voter outreach before the runoff.

What's next

Brazil holds its presidential runoff election on Sunday, Oct. 25. Before the vote, electoral authorities face questions over how they will monitor and audit Meta's proprietary algorithms and WhatsApp AI guardrails for compliance, as well as whether the court will grant a request from Lula's campaign to double its organic reach as compensation for alleged delivery suppression.

Sources · 3 reports

Spotted an error? Write to [email protected]. Tags: Brazil, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, Flávio Bolsonaro, Meta, Artificial intelligence, Elections.